Abstract

This book presents a sophisticated, ambitious, and very valuable reading of Hegel's "absolute idealist" philosophy as being committed to a position of epistemological realism. Westphal's method of approach incorporates two basic levels of analysis. First, the work gives a very close examination of the "Introduction" to the Phenomenology of Spirit, tracing out the structure of Hegel's argument for epistemological realism and the way in which a successful realism requires a socio-historical grounding of knowledge. Second, Westphal spends a good deal of time showing how Hegel's concerns are intimately related to attempts within the history of philosophy to develop epistemologies which could withstand certain fundamental challenges of skepticism. Here he relies on a close reading of a number of Sextus Empiricus' most basic arguments. He considers the efforts of Descartes, Kant, Carnap, and William Alston, and argues that each in different ways fails to meet these challenges, while a careful reconstruction of Hegel's own position yields a more successful result. This second level of Westphal's analysis serves the much needed goal of emphasizing how Hegel's theory of knowledge ought to be placed within the mainstream of epistemological debates.