Abstract

The author traces the motley and fascinating history of two shapes of philosophical history, the cyclical and progressive. In the first five chapters his interpretations are sensitive, the language vigorous, elegant, and learned. His accounts of Augustine and Joachim, the Renaissance and early Kant are particularly good. Unfortunately, in his treatment of German philosophical history his scholarship breaks down. He claims, for example, that Hegel's encounter with French history aroused only hostility and rejection, when in fact Hegel regarded the French as "on a higher level of universal and national culture" than the Germans in understanding history. Chapter 6 sees Hegel a proponent of the vita contemplativa; certainly his greatness lay in altering the very conception of "life" and contributing the decisive influence on the most activist philosophy of all time. Manuel falsely links Hegel's idea of the Germanic world with race theory, and presses to a crooked conclusion: the Germans looked on everything foreign as inimical. Hegel's unexampled ideal was a knowledge of all cultures and universal freedom.—M. M.