Human Nature or Humanity: Between Genes and Values
Abstract
We are within nature and culture, conditioned simultaneously by genes and
meanings. This form of our self-understanding is the result of fundamental
modifications that happened in modern philosophical anthropology and of
the impact of the natural Science. In modern philosophy three types of
approaches to the human situation were constituted at different times: the
idealist, the naturalist, and the culturalist, and the problem of whether
humanity is natural (biological) or cultural has begun to take precedence over
the issue of human supernatural roots. Both approaches are presented, their
presuppositions discussed, and arguments in favor of a version of the
culturalist approach. Only the culturalist approach allows us to understand
our own self-constitution and, in particular, our self-reflectivity, as well as the
naturalist attempts to ignore them and immerse ourselves in nature.