Abstract

In this article, I am interested in forming an account of how an atheist (which I define as someone who believes that God does not exist) might have faith in God. Assuming an involuntarism position regarding the nature of belief, I examine whether an atheist could have non-doxastic propositional faith in God, but conclude that this is not possible since it would force an individual to believe that_ p_ might exist and that _p _does not exist at (what I call) a first-order level, which is impossible. I then examine accounts of objectual faith (faith in _S_) and suggest that they may offer hope for the faithful atheist. Specifically, it appears that, in certain limited cases that I refer to as _objectual roles_, the object of one’s faith may shift (a phenomenon that I call a “transfer”) depending on who or what brings a given state of affairs about (so long as the enactor of this state of affairs meets the requirement of the role). This strange feature of objectual faith allows for one to have faith in someone or something even if one does not believe in its existence. I conclude by examining how the possible implications of this project may impact Christian theology in particular.