This article aims to characterise the visions of ecologisation found within scientific approaches embraced by different epistemic communities, and which have inspired empirical work and public action on agrifood system transitions. Based on comparative readings of works anchored in our two disciplinary fields (ecology and sociology), we identified six large ensembles of epistemic communities as well as their points of convergence and divergence. We identify six ideotypical visions of ecologisation based on the types of ‘relationships to nature’ embedded in these (...) large sets of epistemic communities: protectionism, functionalism, structuralism, post-structuralism, relational and pragmatist-experience-based. We suggest that pragmatist-experience-based approaches allow us to transcend two classical oppositions: between realism and constructivism, and between a conception of nature as passive and external as opposed to active and relational. Without claiming to offer a detailed analysis of these approaches, we hope that our work can be used as a tool to support reflection among scientists and other actors involved in agrifood system transitions. (shrink)

This paper provides a typology of appeals to authority, identifying three distinct types: that which is based on a command; that which is based on expertise; and that which is based on dignity. Each type is distinguished with respect to the reaction that a failure to follow it ordinarily evokes. The rhetorical roots of Locke's ad verecundiam are traced to the rhetorical practices of ancient Rome.

We reexamine some of the classic problems connected with the use of cardinal utility functions in decision theory, and discuss Patrick Suppes's contributions to this field in light of a reinterpretation we propose for these problems. We analytically decompose the doctrine of ordinalism, which only accepts ordinal utility functions, and distinguish between several doctrines of cardinalism, depending on what components of ordinalism they specifically reject. We identify Suppes's doctrine with the major deviation from ordinalism that conceives of utility functions as (...) representing preference differences, while being non- etheless empirically related to choices. We highlight the originality, promises and limits of this choice-based cardinalism. (shrink)

The poor performances of typically developing children younger than 4 in the first-order false-belief task “Maxi and the chocolate” is analyzed from the perspective of conversational pragmatics. An ambiguous question asked by an adult experimenter (perceived as a teacher) can receive different interpretations based on a search for relevance, by which children according to their age attribute different intentions to the questioner, within the limits of their own meta-cognitive knowledge. The adult experimenter tells the child the following story of object-transfer: (...) “Maxi puts his chocolate into the green cupboard before going out to play. In his absence, his mother moves the chocolate from the green cupboard to the blue one.” The child must then predict where Maxi will pick up the chocolate when he returns. To the child, the question from an adult (a knowledgeable person) may seem surprising and can be understood as a question of his own knowledge of the world, rather than on Maxi's mental representations. In our study, without any modification of the initial task, we disambiguate the context of the question by (1) replacing the adult experimenter with a humanoid robot presented as “ignorant” and “slow” but trying to learn and (2) placing the child in the role of a “mentor” (the knowledgeable person). Sixty-two typical children of 3 years-old completed the first-order false belief task “Maxi and the chocolate,” either with a human or with a robot. Results revealed a significantly higher success rate in the robot condition than in the human condition. Thus, young children seem to fail because of the pragmatic difficulty of the first-order task, which causes a difference of interpretation between the young child and the experimenter. (shrink)

Work and Experience of Domination in Contemporary Neoliberalism This paper seeks to study the contemporary forms of domination at and through work, by focusing on subjective experiences of work. Against the background of Marx’s analysis of the manyfold nexus between social and political domination in general and domination at work, I begin by drawing in broad strokes the general picture of current experiences of work emerging from the contemporary French sociology and psychology of work. Related to this rich literature but (...) also contrasting with it, the psychodynamic approach developed by Christophe Dejours seems particularly significant, notably because its provides a consistent model explaining the links between subjective experience, social interactions beyond work, material conditions of production, and broad cultural and political factors. From the psychodynamic model arises an original analysis of the current forms of domination and alienation at work, one, I argue in conclusion, which could substantially inform the current attempt to develop a new “social philosophy”. (shrink)

Introduction -- Ruling the household -- Humans as political animals -- Slavery -- Wives -- Wealth and the proper aims of ruling the household -- Justice -- Good citizens -- Good constitutions -- Friendship -- The scope and aims of political philosophy -- The best constitution -- The best for most -- The best for each -- The preservation of all and any constitutions and regimes.

Hay muchos retratos de Spinoza, pero ninguno de ellos está bien documentado, al menos suficientemente documentado como para satisfacer las exigencias del método iconográfico. Por falta de argumentos objetivos que permitan identificar a Spinoza entre tantos cuadros y grabados, tal vez podamos considerar que el “verdadero” retrato de Spinoza es el frontispicio de las Opera posthuma de 1677.

What is the point of praying if God does not exist? Iris Murdoch answers: to see the Good and to be able to accomplish it. Indeed, although it presents itself as atheist, Iris Murdoch's philosophy (as well as her literature) gives the practice of prayer a preponderant place in the moral conduct of our lives. This article seeks to explain this seemingly paradoxical position by explaining its metaethical background: inscribed in the moral ontology, epistemology and psychology of Iris Murdoch, a (...) practice of attention like that of prayer seems to be able to be effective, and to occasion the grace of a precious moral enlightenment. (shrink)

We define and examine a notion of logical friendliness, which is a broadening of the familiar notion of classical consequence. The concept is tudied first in its simplest form, and then in a syntax-independent version, which we call sympathy. We also draw attention to the surprising number of familiar notions and operations with which it makes contact, providing a new light in which they may be seen.

La fameuse « Préface-annexe » de La Religieuse reprend le texte de la « confession » que, dix ans plus tôt, Grimm avait publié dans son périodique pour confesser son rôle dans la mystification qui avait été jouée au marquis de Croismare. La « reprise » de Diderot accompagne la résurrection du roman que Grimm avait enterré, sans se soucier des affirmations contradictoires qui en résultent. La polygraphie de Diderot est polyphonie ; elle participe de la représentation des pouvoirs de (...) l’écriture, que conquiert Suzanne, l’héroïne du roman. (shrink)

The lush surreal illustrations of this book and its short humoristic story telling make it a fun, quick read for all ages and for anyone obliquely interested in our thirst for development and the nature of who we are. Through a poetic parody of human's desires for more of everything, we become aware that such a quest does not bring us any closer to knowing ourselves or seeing, as contemporary scientific or spiritual leaders are telling us: all things and beings (...) of our planet are intimately related, alive and ultimately "One." While each colorful painting alludes to our close relationship with the world, short lines innocently and wryly comment on the predicaments of our lives pertaining to the industrial world, where dream and reality often appear intertwined. Through the shifting identities of forms, this album gives us a glance at our own formless nature and how our excessive wish for love, home, comfort, power, and productivity inexorably transforms our worldview and make us bypass our deep infinite nature, which cannot be contained through words. As some indigenous traditions have taught us: "life is like a dream. One wonders whether it is by living that we dream or by dreaming that we live.". (shrink)

Le principe de non-contradiction a depuis très longtemps étéreconnu comme le principe le plus fondamental de la pensée rationnelle. II est facile de l'énoncer sous sa forme symbolique: –. Ce principe pose que quelqu'un ne saurait affirmer en même temps une proposition et sa négation. Pour que ce principe ne demeure pas une exigence vide, il faut en outre que l'on puisse déterminer avec précision quelles sont les conditions de son application. Cette détermination des conditions d'application d'un principe commence par (...) la recherche des moyens par lesquels il est possible de démarquer, dans le champ de son application, ce qui en respecte l'énoncé de ce qui n'en respecte pas l'énoncé. Or si rien n'est plus facile que de formuler un précepte, rien, appa-remment, n'est plus difficile que de tracer une ligne nette entre ce qui se conforme au précepte et ce qui le transgresse. Bien qu'il soit l'assise la plus profonde de nos raisonnements, le principe de non-contradiction ne fait pas exception à ce constat. Son énoncé fait sans doute l'unanimité mais il est assez rare que l'on s'accorde, en dehors des disciplines formelles, sur ce qui constitue l'occurrence d'une contradiction. Cet accord sur ce qui constitue ou non l'exemple d'une contradiction m'apparaît faire défaut d'une façon particulièrement marquée en philosophic Cette situation pose un double problème. (shrink)

Dans le précédent numéro de Methodos j’avais fait un compte-rendu de la traduction du De beryllo (Traité du béryl) de Nicolas de Cues, proposée par Maude Corrieras (M. C.). Je considérais que cette traduction s’inscrivait dans la suite des récentes traductions en français d’œuvres du cusain, et je concluais : la traduction proposée du Traité du béryl est une aide estimable à la compréhension de la démarche de Nicolas de Cues, sans que pour autant ce traité puisse se substituer aux (...) grands text... (shrink)

À travers une suite d’œuvres qui cherchaient toujours un autre but, Lévi-Strauss dessine tout de même les contours d’une éthique qui prend acte d’un certain nihilisme - la vie humaine n’a pas un sens qu’elle pourrait « découvrir » et elle ne saurait non plus donner son sens au monde -. Il détermine, en particulier, quelques caractéristiques d’une éthique qui veille à la protection de toutes les cultures et à la préservation de la terre qui abrite tous les vivants et (...) qui verra la fin de l’homme comme elle a connu la fin de tant d’espèces. Le lecteur de Lévi-Strauss s’étonne de constater que le structuralisme que l’auteur met en œuvre par méthode dans son travail anthropologique s’associe à un usage de fictions quand il s’agit de tracer une éthique. Notre enquête consiste à examiner cette association un peu étrange qui fait ressortir que, sans adhérer à l’utilitarisme, qui use d’une théorie des fictions, l’auteur se sert de cette dernière sur des points stratégiques pour éviter les dialectiques de style kantien et hégélien, c’est-à-dire pour que les oppositions se fassent contrepoids entre elles et pour que les contradictions puissent se résoudre en plis plutôt que se déchirer entre elles. (shrink)

Modern barbarity will soon get rid of the human species unless a new form of violence is found able to compete with the state, without turning into a new form a state. This new form is authoritative, legitimate intimidation. But what are the conditions to speak out authoritatively? Are they not distinctive state conditions? Moreover, does authority lie in the form of discourse? If not, because consentment has superseded mere submission, which are the authoritative sources of discourse which, though neither (...) overtly nor primarily conflicting with the state, nor with corporations, could somehow not completely coincide with the interests of it and even work against it, though like it? This paper examines these questions. (shrink)

There are many ways in which language can describe the dependency of one occurrence on another and hence many varieties of conditional construction, including conditionals in ‘if’, ‘when’, ‘since’, and ‘as’, the absolutive conditionals of Stump (1985), and the correlative conditional construction (‘the more, the merrier’) discussed in Fillmore (1986). This paper will be concerned with investigating one species illustrated in (1a) and (1b).

Sein und Zeit entendait repeter la question de l'etre, mais commencait par une analytique de la quotidiennete. Or, si notre epoque est peu encline a assumer le projet d'une Fundamentalontologie, du moins s'est-elle emparee du quotidien jusqu'a l'eriger en authentique paradigme. Le present travail, prenant acte de ce paradigme en tachant d'en circonscrire conceptuellement l'emergence quelle est sa fonction dans la pensee du XXe siecle, et a quel type de necessite repond-il? se propose de montrer que le probleme de la (...) quotidiennete, en projetant la philosophie dans l'espace d'une difference ou elle ne s'institue que dans le mouvement par lequel elle se saisit de ce qu'elle n'est pas, se situe au cur de la demarche phenomenologique, et permet par la meme d'en interroger les fondements. Aussi entreprenons-nous d'abord de faire valoir, par une lecture interne de certains moments cles de son histoire, et en insistant particulierement sur l'equivocite caracterisant a cet egard la Fundamentalontologie heideggerienne, qu'un tel probleme devoile dans le projet phenomenologique certaines failles architectoniques dans lesquelles une pensee de la publicite comme celle de Wittgenstein permet de s'engouffrer pour autant qu'elle en conteste le geste d'auto-fondation. Puis, a la lumiere de ce qu'une telle approche s'avere a son tour susceptible de nous reveler quant au sens de notre quotidiennete, nous tentons, sur un mode cette fois positif et en echo a la pensee du second Heidegger et a sa redetermination rarement soulignee du theme de l'Alltaglichkeit de cerner la possibilite d'une repetition de la question de l'etre liberee de ses presupposes ontologico-phenomenologiques initiaux. (shrink)

Résumé Nous verrons que le désintérêt à peine voilé de Michael Sheringham, comme de Philippe Lejeune avant lui, à l’ égard des Mémoires d’ une jeune fille rangée tient à leur valorisation excessive du pacte autobiographique. Or, tout en s’ inscrivant dans la nébuleuse des autobiographies existentialistes, le récit de Simone de Beauvoir s’ en démarque, en particulier par le rôle qu’ y joue le genre des Mémoires en creux, ou plus précisément à l’ horizon du texte de 1958. Il (...) s’ agira de montrer que le premier volume du cycle beauvoirien occupe au sein des récits de soi existentialistes une place beaucoup plus centrale que ne l’ envisageait Sheringham dans French Autobiography. (shrink)

Cet ouvrage offre une présentation magistrale de l'enseignement portant sur l'âme dans les années 1230-1235 à Paris par un maître en théologie réputé pour sa clarté. Il permet d'évaluer l'état de la réflexion sur l'âme à l'orée du travail de réinterprétation de l'aristotélisme tel que le véhiculait la tradition gréco-arabe par Albert le Grand et Thomas d'Aquin.

The essay revisits Deleuze and Guattari’s complex relation to Marxism, which it seeks to capture under the name para-Marxism, by way of a close reading of plateau n? 4 of A Thousand Plateaus, which criticizes the mainstream conception of language and draws on Lenin’s pamphlet on slogans. This close reading leads to an account of the articulation of the Deleuze and Guattari machine with the Marxist analysis of language, to be found, for purposes of comparison in Lukacs’s Ontology. The conclusion (...) is that Deleuze and Guattari’s conception of language is an intervention within Marxism: they take to its limit the anti-humanist position defended by Althusser – not so much a flight away from Marxism as a line of flight within Marxism. (shrink)

Este artigo tenta mostrar como a concepção hobbesiana de corpo, longe de ser uma mera metáfora ou o efeito de uma redução fisicalista, constitui antes uma significação primeira para toda ciência possível. A partir dela, é possível pensar o que é o corpo político sem cair em ilusões substancialistas ou totalizantes.